Illogical reaction

ON ASH Wednesday, I tried to evacuate with my three toddlers. This was a mistake. We became trapped and sat out the conflagration in a park in Upper Beaconsfield. It felt like a war zone. In the meantime, my husband and a neighbour fought for their lives in a foot of water in Cardinia Creek. They were lucky to survive. Nevertheless, we have since planted 50,000 trees.

John Brumby's decision to encourage extensive vegetation removal in the green wedges shows he has little understanding of the complexities of bushfire behaviour. This autocratic kneejerk reaction to Black Saturday is illogical and counterproductive.

Rosalie Counsell, Harkaway

The Age, Letters to the Editor, 7th September 2009.

Comments

Andrew Campbell's response to Black Saturday - must read

The most comprehensive refutation of the hysteria surrounding Black Saturday I have read would be Andrew Campbell's essay, found on his consultancy site. It is lengthy but definitely worth a read if you have the time. Links to a number of other expert statements can also be found on this page:

http://www.triplehelix.com.au/Bushfires.html