Letters

Letters to the editor and other community comments

Fix death traps

SO MUCH talk. So little done. So few days to the next fire season and the only substantial measure in place from the Government has been the ''10/30'' land-clearing provisions overriding conservation zones, overlays and heritage controls across my municipality and 10 others in outer-urban ''green wedges''.

llogical reaction

ON ASH Wednesday, I tried to evacuate with my three toddlers. This was a mistake. We became trapped and sat out the conflagration in a park in Upper Beaconsfield. It felt like a war zone. In the meantime, my husband and a neighbour fought for their lives in a foot of water in Cardinia Creek. They were lucky to survive. Nevertheless, we have since planted 50,000 trees.

School clearing another example of Brumby's ill conceived "quick fix" solutions.

Since Brumby's 10/30 legislation came in, there has been strenuous debate amongst hills residents.  This shows the depth of concern that many residents feel about the effect this legislation will have on our beautiful environment, climate chance, tourism and quality of life, all while not guaranteeing any of us will be safer from bushfire this coming season, or in future fire seasons.

Catching fire bugs

A RECENT study by the Australian Institute of Criminology estimated about half of Australia's bushfires were lit deliberately. Few arsonists are caught or convicted. This activity is likely to increase on days of code-red fire risk. Arsonists have received little attention following February's terrible fires. It is imperative that this criminal activity be addressed, perhaps by adopting measures similar to South Australia's Operation Nomad, in which police visit suspected and convicted arsonists on days of high fire danger and use automated number plate recognition to alert them when suspects drive in fire danger zones. This would be resource-intensive, but surely a fraction of the cost and logistical effort required to combat fires and their dreadful aftermath.

Dick Davies, president, Warrandyte Community Association 

 

comment from member Phil Burrell

 I have been a firefighter for many years (CFA's in South Aust, Tasmania, RFS in NSW, Remote area firefighter for NSW National Parks and Wildlife Service 1989-1998, author of bushfire training manual, "Pumps and Pumping" ;Crew Leader training NPWS.) The Australian bush is unique and essential, but we cannot expect to see sound planning in housing standards anytime soon in bushfire prone areas. The town of Marysville is one example. The Victorian Govt should offer to purchase all burnt or unburnt housing or business alotments at market price and turn Marysville into a "Historic Precinct" and give people the chance to build elsewhere and reduce the heartache of the burden of the "go or stay to defend" decision making from people who may not be in the position to make rational decisions in an emergency situation.

An example of a letter sent from a member to Brett Ellis - Shire of Yarra Ranges

 to: Shire of Yarra Ranges 

 

 

 

attention: Mr Brett Ellis, Executive Officer for Emergency and Safety Planning

 

Dear Mr Ellis

 

Council Tree Felling Regulations

 

As you will be no doubt aware, the state government has legislated to permit residents to remove trees and vegetation within 10 and 30 metres from their homes.

 

Personally, I consider this legislation to be potentially environmentally destructive and does not provide for better fire safety due to the protection that trees provide from winds and ember attack and that this activity itself will create safety and fire hazards. However, it is likely that some residents will take up Premier Brumby's offer and remove trees and vegetation.

Example of letter sent from a member to James Merlino

 Dear Mr Merlino MHR
 
STOP environment destruction now Repeal 10/30 regulations
 
It has been reported to me that the government has legislated for the clearing of trees under the 10/30 proposal aired on talk back radio, there are several points I would like to make.
 
There has been no public consultation prior to this legislation being passed. The rantings of talkback radio shock jocks and those who listen to this media are no substitute for public consultation and properly considered policy.
 
- This legislation overrides local democracy and planning laws

Shades of silliness

IN LESS than a week, contractors will start tree and vegetation removal at many schools, including Don Valley Primary School, simply because these schools were designed to protect students and staff if bushfire threatens.
 

These trees are the only source of shade at our school. Statistics will show that our children are at a far greater risk of contracting skin cancer than they are of dying as a result of bushfire. As the Department of Education intends to close schools on days of extreme fire risk anyway, the likelihood of the buildings being occupied is remote. We had two days when this occurred last season - but 159 days when the Sun Smart policy required the wearing of sun protection.

Empty paddocks burn too

TALKBACK radio should not be the only place informing government policy - why not use the far more considered outcomes of the royal commission? What will become of all the roadside plantings, wildlife corridors and shelter-belts that Landcare groups have worked hard to create? Many of these plantings were taxpayer-subsidised. What about threatened or endangered flora - how will residents know what they are chopping down?

Syndicate content